PBOT won’t enforce bike lane parking on NE 33rd as it ‘cleans up’ removal mistake

Looking north on NE 33rd from the middle of NE Holman. (Photo: Jonathan Maus/BikePortland)

The Portland Bureau of Transportation says what transpired on Northeast 33rd was “an embarrassing public mistake” and they are in the process of cleaning it up.

Their planned removal of two blocks of bike lanes on 33rd was met with a direct action protest that prevented crews from completing the job. Then a PR debacle ensued.

I had a phone call today with the PBOT communications director and the high-level staffer who’s taking full blame for the situation (no, it was not PBOT Director Millicent Williams or Commissioner Mingus Mapps). I learned more about PBOT’s version for how it all went sideways. I’ll have that story up soon, but wanted to share something I just received a few minutes ago from someone who lives on NE 33rd where the bike lane was installed.

On Tuesday morning, residents along the two block stretch of 33rd between Holman and Dekum received a letter on their doorstep. It said, “beginning Wednesday, November 1… PBOT will deploy contractors to remove lane striping in this section and return this section to its original condition.”

Today, those same residents received another letter from PBOT. Below is the text of that letter (emphasis mine):

Dear Northeast Portland Neighbor,

I am writing to follow up on the recently installed bike lanes along NE 33rd Avenue. The Portland Bureau of Transportation (PBOT) installed bike lanes on NE 33rd from NE Holman to NE Dekum streets at the beginning of October, effectively removing on-street parking for these two blocks. PBOT did not give adequate notices to the adjacent residents, and we immediately heard concerns from residents with hardships presented from removing the on-street parking.

PBOT continued to communicate with the concerned residents and ultimately decided to remove bike lane striping in this section and return it to its original condition with on-street parking. Contractors started to perform this work on November 1st. However, work was stopped when protesting in the streets made it unsafe to continue the work. At this time, there is no schedule for the removal of the bike lane striping to continue. We recommend not parking in the bike lanes, but at the same time we do not plan to issue tickets with fines.

We would like to take this time to continue our conversations with directly impacted residents to ensure access and safety needs are being met before we continue with any additional action. We are also having conversations with area cyclists that support the bike lanes. If you have a concern you would like to share with PBOT, please call, email, or set up a time for us to meet in person. We will continue engagement and notify the community before taking any further action.

An extant bike lane that won’t be legally treated like one, is a really awkward — and potentially dangerous — situation. It sets people up for verbal or even physical interactions on the street — in the form of both potential traffic collisions and potential disagreements between how the road should be used.

This situation underscores what a mess PBOT finds themselves in for the second time in the past month or so.

From what I heard from PBOT’s Policy, Planning & Projects Group Director Art Pearce today, the city is in a really awkward position too. “It’s an uncomfortable moment for me,” Pearce shared with BikePortland in a video call a few hours ago. “This mistake happened under my watch.” Pearce is taking full responsibility for what happened on 33rd. Now it’s his job to clean up the mess before it gets worse.

Stay tuned for a recap of that conversation. And be careful biking on 33rd Avenue until this all gets sorted out.

Weekend Event Guide: Fall colors, warehouse sale, sausage fest more

North Williams Ave just north of Russell. (Photo: Jonathan Maus/BikePortland)

Welcome to the weekend.

Check out our ride and event picks below.

Saturday, November 4th

2023 Oregon Cyclocross Championships – All Day in Mollala, OR
An OBRA champ jersey is on the line at the new Fernwood course in Molalla. Make it a weekend, because Sunday is race #5 of the Cyclocross Crusade series at the same venue. More info here.

Showers Pass Warehouse Sale – 9:00 am to 4:00 pm at Showers Pass HQ (2101 SE 6th)
The massive annual sale is on and it’s your chance for big deals on not just SP raingear, but also: Vvolt e-bikes, Portland Design Works parts, bags from Black Stone Stitchworks, Coava Coffee, and more. Get their early before the good stuff is gone!

Verboort Sausage Ride – 9:30 am at Shute Park (Hillsboro)
You heard about it on the BikePortland podcast, now it’s time to see the sausage fest for yourself! And getting their by bike means you’ll burn the calories you’ll consume in beer and brats. More info here.

Fall Colors of Portland – 2:00 pm at Pod 28 (SE)
Get all your leaf-peeping done in one convenient ride. Scott B will lead you on a tour of trees in all the best neighborhoods. More info here.

Dead Baby Bikes Monthly Ride – 7:30 pm (ride at 9:00) at Rocky’s Sports & Spirits (SE)
Yes it’s a bike club. But all are welcome to join. If you like freak bikes and fun, creative, bike-riding folks, these just might be your people. More info here.

Sunday, November 5th

Cyclocross Crusade Race #5 – All day in Mollala (OR)
It’s the penultimate race in the illustrious, 30th annual series. More info here.

Bike Train to Thorns Playoff Match – 12:30 pm at Moda Center (N)
Join cycling soccer fans for a ride to support the Thorns in their first playoff match. Ticket to get into the match required. More info here.


— Don’t see an event? Please tell us about what’s going on in your neighborhood by filling out our contact form!

The morning after: A look at media coverage of 33rd Avenue

24 hours ago I was on my bike, racing over to Northeast 33rd after seeing a video online of a PBOT contractor in a truck removing the bike lane. What ensued was an unprecedented direct action that saved the bike lane and stories and social media videos that have been viewed by hundreds of thousands of people around the country (thanks TikTok algorithm!).

Unlike the Southwest Broadway scandal, PBOT’s decision to remove a new bike lane due to what they say was a bungled public outreach process, has led to widespread media attention. To many in the local media, Broadway seemed like a “bike community” thing and the story barely transcended BikePortland. Now PBOT’s bad decisions are (unfortunately) a trend. And in the news business, trends get attention.

Three local TV stations had relatively good coverage of yesterday’s protest. All three sides — protestors, residents, and PBOT — were given airtime. Voices of protestors, especially Cully neighborhood resident and veteran bike advocate Kiel Johnson, dominated the stories.

KOIN (CBS affiliate) said PBOT’s rationale for the removal of the bike lane was an “internal error.” To me, one of the interesting takeaways from KOIN’s coverage (and other stations) was that it mentioned Broadway and its possible connection to the 33rd removal plans.

Here was KOIN’s (CBS affiliate) lead-in: “… This also is the second bike lane that the city’s transportation bureau is planning to take out… PBOT says those two bike lane removals are unrelated, but cyclists tell me they don’t believe that.”

KGW (NBC affiliate) story was short. They said the bike lane was “mistakenly installed without public outreach,” and shared an interview with Johnson.

KPTV (Fox affiliate) did a particularly solid job on the story. They framed opposition to the bike lane in terms of how it impacted parking in front of homes (this jibes with what I’ve learned from various sources in the past day, that the genesis of PBOT’s decision is from complaints about parking loss).

“People living on a four block stretch of Northeast 33rd Avenue are dealing with parking problems after they say changes were made without their input,” the KPTV reporter said. Then continued: “Neighbors say there’s already a greenway route two blocks over from Northeast 33rd Avenue and the bike lanes are not necessary in front of their homes.”

The reporter then interviewed a Black woman who has lived on NE 33rd for 30 years.

“We were surprised to say the least,” the woman said. “These bold, vibrant, thick white lines glaring at us Sunday morning… This had no respect. It was a slap in the face… To me it’s the height of privilege, because when you disregard people’s livelihoods and their feelings.”

So here we are.

Given what PBOT told other news outlets yesterdays, it’s clear that the removal is paused for now. From here, I’d expect some sort of communication from PBOT to the neighbors about a meeting where the bike lane plans will be vetted out a bit more. It’s hard to say what might come of that, or what might come of anything at this point.

After what happened yesterday, and what happened on Broadway, we are in uncharted territory with current PBOT leadership. Stay tuned.

Video: Giving NYC’s bikeways the crosstown test

It’s one thing for a city to have a marquee bike project here or there — but it’s another thing entirely to get people across town by bike on a connected network that is legible and safe.

During my recent trip to New York City, I had to get to Williamsburg, Brooklyn for a story. I was staying in the Flatiron/Chelsea area (W 24th and 6th). I figured this would be a good crosstown test, so I filmed the entire thing. The video above shows the highlights. It gives you a sense of what it’s like to bike about 5 miles through Manhattan, over a bridge, and then into a borough.

My route.

You’ll see a very wide variety of bikeways. I rode through: pedestrianized streets with world-class bikeways; old-school, door-zone bike lanes; shared, low-volume streets; dedicated paths, and more. Overall, I was impressed with NYC’s bike network, despite its chaos and rough edges.

In my opinion (which might be different than yours, given my experience and love of urban riding), NYC passed the test.

Watch the video to see if you agree. And then ask yourself… Does your city stand up to the crosstown test?

See you at Bike Happy Hour later today

It rained last week and we still had a great turnout! Note that tonight we’ll be across the street at Ankeny Tap & Table.

Hell yes we are still having Bike Happy Hour today. Given the weather, we’ll gather on the ground floor of Ankeny Tap & Table, across the street from the usual spot on the patio. Come over to SE Ankeny and 27th to find great people, open hearts and minds, and good food and drinks.

With the unbelievable shenanigans happening at PBOT, we have a lot to talk about.

If nothing else, we can compare rainwear and winter gear recommendations.

I also have a new a-frame sign that will make its debut. And of course I’ll bring the speaker and mic in case anyone feels like sharing to the group. Any city council candidates out there want to show your bona fides by showing up to a rainy Bike Happy Hour?

Hope to see you there!

Bike Happy Hour – Every Wednesday All Year Long
3:00 to 6:00 pm
Gorges Beer Co / Ankeny Tap – SE Ankeny & 27th (On the “Rainbow Road plaza!)
$2 off drinks (includes non-alcoholic and coffee from Crema)
BikeHappyHour.com“See you Wednesday!”

Portlanders stand in front of truck to prevent bike lane removal

Cully resident Kiel Johnson in front of a lane-striping truck on NE 33rd this morning. (Photos: Jonathan Maus/BikePortland)

A group of concerned Portlanders stepped in front of a moving truck this morning to defend a bike lane. The truck was being driven by a contractor hired by the Portland Bureau of Transportation to grind off a recently installed bike lane on Northeast 33rd Avenue in the Concordia neighborhood.

As we reported yesterday, PBOT said the bike lane — that was installed as part of a repaving project in late September — was installed by “mistake” because they didn’t do enough public outreach.

The removal was not announced publicly, and we only found out because PBOT staff warned BikePortland anonymously that it was imminent.

Local bike advocacy nonprofit BikeLoud PDX responded by telling members to show up at the site this morning. The idea was to take a closer look at the bike lanes in advance of a planned strategy session later this morning. However, crews had already begun removing the bike lane as the activists showed up. One of them, former BikeLoud PDX Chair Kiel Johnson, rolled up to the scene and immediately stopped his bike in front of the oncoming truck. The truck driver stopped and Johnson stood there with his arms crossed.

As several other people rolled up, they massed along with Johnson in front of the truck and a stalemate ensued as contractors whipped out phones to try and figure out what to do.

One of the contractors told the group they were simply there to modify the bike lanes, not remove them. But that contention doesn’t square with PBOT’s statements.

It is clear that PBOT wanted this bike lane removed. Their statement to BikePortland yesterday was unambiguous. It said, “This segment of bike lane was installed by mistake and will be removed.”

And a nearby resident shared with BikePortland this morning that just this morning a letter from PBOT was placed on their door. It read:

“Dear Northeast Portland Neighbor,

I am writing to notify you of construction beginning tomorrow, Wednesday November 1, 2023 on NE 33rd Avenue from NE Holman to NE Dekum streets. The Portland Bureau of Transportation (PBOT) will deploy contractors to remove lane striping in this section and return this section to its original condition.”

If people didn’t show up this morning, the bike lane would be gone.

Once the truck operator left the corner of NE 33rd and Holman, he simply moved to another section of the bike lane a few blocks south and started the grinding-off process again. Activists then hopped on their bikes and stood in front to stop forward progress.

Several minutes passed and the truck left once again.

Eventually the contractors left for the day, but BikeLoud volunteers are still there. They’re staying in shifts to make sure the trucks don’t return.

This bike lane closes a key gap in the bike network and it’s called out as a planned “city bikeway” in the Transportation System Plan. It was also recommended as a high priority in the Columbia/Lombard Mobility Plan passed by Portland City Council in 2021.

Commissioner Mingus Mapps, who leads PBOT, voted in support of that plan.

Reached for comment today, his Deputy Chief of Staff Cynthia Castro said, “PBOT is not continuing with removing the bike lane today, but we do need to have further conversation about this particular stretch.”

Asked if Mapps’ office authorized the order to remove the bike lane, Castro said, “I would say that I’m on the same page with the [PBOT] director as far as saying, ‘We need to have more conversation about this particular stretch,’ and obviously there’s a lot of lessons learned here about outreach.

But PBOT Director Millicent Williams isn’t on that page. Based on PBOT statements and that letter given to residents this morning, Director Williams did not plan to have any further conversation. The order was to remove the bike lane and it would be gone if not for the timely protest organized by BikeLoud PDX.

Stay tuned.

PBOT plans to remove new bike lanes on NE 33rd

New bike lanes striped on NE 33rd at NE Holman. (Photos: Jonathan Maus/BikePortland)

New buffered bike lanes on Northeast 33rd Avenue that have only been installed for about one month are slated for removal by the Portland Bureau of Transportation. That’s according to a source who works at the bureau and who shared the information with BikePortland anonymously because they aren’t authorized to speak to the media.

In addition to the source I’ve had direct contact with, the news has spread into the community from other sources and is widely known internally at PBOT. I’ve asked PBOT to confirm or deny the tip, but they have not yet responded.

Here’s the backstory and what I know right now…

PBOT repaved NE 33rd Avenue between NE Knott and Columbia Blvd this summer. As part of that project, they restriped the road and added bike lanes in several sections. We’ve reported on the new bikeway on 33rd between Skidmore and Mason*, but I hadn’t been able to get to the new bike lanes between NE Holman and Dekum (just south of Columbia Blvd overpass) until this morning. (*Keep in mind, this story is only about the northern section of new bike lanes between Holman and Dekum, not the new crossing at Mason-Skidmore. That went through a robust neighborhood process and appears to be safe.)

I was motivated to finally go see the new lanes because a source at PBOT said they plan to be removed sometime this week.

The reason? Apparently it stems from bureau leadership saying that proper neighborhood notifications had not been sent out.

My source at PBOT says crews could come out and remove the new bike lanes as early as tomorrow (Wednesday, 11/1).

I saw “No Parking” notifications on the blocks in question during my visit today. The signs say crews will be on hand November 1 through November 3rd.

These new bike lanes were celebrated by some when they were installed in late September. Holman is a major, east-west neighborhood greenway route, and 33rd is a vital gateway to the Marine Drive bike path. The bike lane gap between Holman and the bike lanes on the Lombard/Columbia overpass (and Marine Dr) was always a stressful spot. The new bike lanes closed that gap and created a safer street. This section of 33rd is also classified as a “City Bikeway” in the Portland Transportation System Plan (adopted in 2020).

Detail from Columbia/Lombard Mobility Plan showing recommendation of these bike lanes.

Bike lanes on this section of NE 33rd were also recommended in PBOT’s Columbia/Lombard Mobility Corridor Plan adopted by City Council in 2021. Bike lanes between Holman and the bridge were called out as a “high readiness” recommendation (see graphic at right).

Parking doesn’t seem to be in particularly high demand on these few blocks (although I’ve noticed at least one person who’s parked in the new bike lane every time I’ve been by). It’s zoned single-family and nearly all the houses have driveways. There are two businesses on the northeast corner of Holman and 33rd; a quickie-mart and a restaurant, but both are served by a relatively large parking lot. I’m not aware of any simmering neighborhood revolt or pushback to the project. That being said, these bike lanes did go in relatively quietly and I don’t recall any specific messaging or notice from PBOT about them.

Even if proper public notice wasn’t given, it’s unclear why PBOT would resort to taking the bike lanes out. If this story is confirmed, it would be another cause for concern given that it comes just about five weeks after PBOT Director Millicent Williams was forced to apologize after a plan hatched by Transportation Commissioner Mingus Mapps to roll back the design of the Broadway bike lanes was met with outcry by the community.

I’ve asked PBOT to clarify what’s going on and will update this story when I hear back. I decided to publish this story before hearing back because I have reason to believe the removal of the bike lane could begin as soon as tomorrow (Wednesday, 11/1). Stay tuned.


UPDATE, 5:11 pm: PBOT has confirmed the removal and Communications Director Hannah Schafer just shared this statement:

“This segment of bike lane was installed by mistake and will be removed. A change of this magnitude would only come after significant public outreach, which did not happen as part of this maintenance project. PBOT is investigating and reevaluating its work process to make sure this costly mistake does not occur again.”

UPDATE, 11/1: BikeLoud PDX has sent out an action alert. They will meet for a ride to inspect the bike lane and then have a strategy meeting this morning on how to respond. Read the action alert here.

UPDATE, 11/1: Just posted this video of the bike lane to give you a better sense of what is at stake:

Blumenauer not worried about legacy, says city is poised with policy and political potential

Blumenauer at a press conference in southeast Portland this morning. (Photos: Jonathan Maus/BikePortland)

U.S. Congressman Earl Blumenauer walked slowly into an office building on Southeast 7th Avenue this morning, about one mile south of the carfree bridge that bears his name, and answered questions from reporters for about 30 minutes.

We showed up on short notice after Blumenauer announced yesterday he would not seek another term in office and that his nearly 50-year political career will be over at the end of 2024.

The congressman donned his customary neon bike lapel pin and wore a large white bow-tie with black bikes stenciled on it. He didn’t make a speech and instead opted to simply open it up to questions from about a half-dozen cameras and local reporters.

At the entry to the event there were three stacks of issue papers: “Bikes”, “Cannabis”, and “Livability.” To say Blumenauer was the biggest bicycling champion on Capitol Hill is so obvious it almost doesn’t need to be said.

Given the notable decline in two of three of those high priority issues in Portland in recent years, I wanted to ask Blumenauer if he’s worried his legacy was being squandered — and whether he planned to help Portland get back on track. Before I even got a chance to ask my question however, Blumenauer brought up the subject himself. “I’ve spent a lifetime working on livable communities. And I’m proud of what we did in Portland,” he said. “But the last few years, no one’s going to confuse us with the most livable city in America. And I want to work with people here to change that.”

When I asked him to expand on that and share his thoughts on his legacy being damaged by a lack of local political champions for the issues he cares most about, he said, “I’m not going to abandon bike-partisanship, whether it’s here or around the country.” Then he continued:

“I think what we’ve done in this community is establish a bike culture, and you can’t avoid it. Walking or biking or — God forbid — driving around Portland, it’s pretty firmly embedded. And we’ve got some people who are strong advocates and the infrastructure here is good and it’s getting better.

We’ve got opportunities in a way that we’ve never had before… This last Congress produced more money for biking, for transit, for Amtrak, than ever before; and a very ambitious agenda to reduce carbon emissions. So we’ve got these pieces in place with federal policy.

We’ve got some amazing advocates here. I think it’s a matter of putting the pieces together. I think in the next election there’ll be more people who are willing to embrace and move it forward. So I think it’s it’s just a little below the surface.

We’ve got tremendous opportunities in cycling and transportation infrastructure. Extending the streetcar one mile to Montgomery Park opens up 5,000 housing units! What we’re doing on 82nd Avenue, the number one transit street in the entire system, and the commitment to improving traffic safety, which I hope becomes a higher priority for the general public. And I’m sure it will be for the people who run for office this next year.”

When I chatted with Blumenauer privately before the event he gushed about a recent trip to Bentonville, Arkansas, a city that has fully embraced bicycling and the mantle of America’s most bike-friendly city thanks to a huge infusion of cash and enthusiasm from Walmart.

In many ways, Bentonville is doing what Blumenauer — and many of us in local advocacy circles — were trying to do in Portland before the wheels fell off around 2014 or so.

It would have been impossible to imagine Portland losing its cycling stride back in those heady days in 2008 when Blumenauer was pumping his fists on the House floor after we were named a “Platinum” bicycle-friendly city. It will be just as hard to imagine Portland losing its bicycling champion in Congress.

Bell lap for Blumenauer: 2024 will be his last year in Congress

Blumenauer biking on Pennsylvania Avenue on his way to speak at the 2008 National Bike Summit. (Photos: Jonathan Maus/BikePortland)

In bike racing parlance, “bell lap” is the final lap of a race. Congressman Earl Blumenauer has been in the race for nearly 50 years and 2024 will be his last time around the course.

14 months from now Earl Blumenauer will no longer represent Portland on Capitol Hill. The Democrat who represents Oregon’s third congressional district announced Monday we will not seek reelection next year.

Blumenauer has served in the U.S. House of Representatives for 27 years. Before that, he was the City of Portland’s transportation commissioner where he presided over the creation of Portland’s first Bicycle Master Plan.

For nearly three decades, Blumenauer has been the most vocal and active cycling champion in American politics. He founded the Congressional Bike Caucus in 1996 and helped secure billions in funding for cycling, walking, and transit investments nationwide.

Riding the Eastbank Esplanade in 2009.

In a statement yesterday, Blumenauer appeared to hint that he won’t disappear from the public eye once he’s permanently resettled back home in Portland:

“I have dedicated my career to creating livable communities where people are safe, healthy, and economically secure… There will be time later to reflect on our many accomplishments and where we go from here. Suffice it to say I am looking forward to my next chapter, which includes being a champion of making our community more livable. Portland is broken and I want to help fix it.”

Blumenauer will host a press conference this morning. On the way there I’ll bike over the carfree bridge that bears his name. Stay tuned for more coverage.