Riding along with Molly Fair, a first-time Manhattan bike commuter

Ride Along with Molly Fair-3

Molly Fair (right), was a bit unsure of what her first
bike commute into Manhattan would have in store.
(Photos © J. Maus/BikePortland)

29-year old Brooklyn resident Molly Fair was like many New Yorkers in the aftermath of Sandy. The shutdown of subways and buses left her stranded from her job. Fortunately for her, she had a bike; but that alone wouldn’t have been enough to get her to ride it to work. That’s because, like a lot of New Yorkers (and Portlanders for that matter), Molly felt unsafe riding in traffic.

But the impacts of Sandy, and the bike advocates that swung into action in its aftermath, turned out to be the nudge she needed to give it a try. And I happened to come along for the ride.

Molly is one of many people that hopped aboard a bike train in the days following the big storm. She found out about it on the Transportation Alternatives website and I met her, her boyfriend Jessie Goldstein, and TA volunteer (and our conductor) Chris McNally at Red Lantern Bike Shop on Myrtle Ave, which is conveniently located near the base of the Manhattan Bridge. (Note: NYC Biketrain was co-founded by Kimberly Kinchen after she watched a Streetsfilm about Portland’s bike trains.)

Ride Along with Molly Fair-1

TA volunteer and bike train leader Chris McNally (center) gets ready
to roll inside the Red Lantern bike shop cafe.

“I hate riding in Manahattan,” Molly shared before we rolled out, “during commute hours it’s especially crazy.” “I would rather not get stressed out before I even get to work,” she added.

Ride Along with Molly Fair-2

Just three days after Sandy hit, Molly was ready to face her fears and New York’s vaunted new bikeways would be put to the test.

Leaving the shop in Brooklyn, we easily connected to a buffered bike lane on Flushing Ave. I had learned earlier in the week from a NYC DOT staffer that this section of Flushing is part of the 14 mile Brooklyn Waterfront Greenway. In order to get the space for this buffered bike lane we enjoyed that morning, the DOT removed 300 auto parking spaces.

Flushing Ave buffered bike lane-2

As we rounded the corner and made our way to the Manhattan Bridge approach at Sands Street, we came upon what might be the best example of bike infrastructure I saw on my entire trip.

For two full blocks leading south from Navy Street to the Manhattan Bridge, the NYC DOT has built a center-running, separated-grade, two-way cycle track. For the first block it’s placed up on a mountable curb (which is rounded, so you can roll up or down it with ease). Where the cycle track crosses a street, there are bike-only signals.

Manhattan Bridge approach-3-1

Manhattan Bridge approach-6-1

As Sands approaches the bridge, the path then becomes its own bike highway in the middle of the road, separated from auto traffic by a full concrete median on both sides.

Manhattan Bridge approach-5

Ride Along with Molly Fair-4

Manhattan Bridge approach-7

At the next intersection, there’s another bike-only signal and a diagonal crossing that takes you right up onto the bridge path. Once up on the bridge, the path serves bike traffic well, although it’s a bit narrow. As New York City bike traffic goes up, this (and many other) key paths will be over-capacity.

Manhattan Bridge traffic-1

And it’s beautiful at night!

Manhattan Bridge at night

So far, Molly was doing great. But we still hadn’t reached Manhattan.

Rolling over the East River into Manhattan, we made our way to Allen St. What the DOT is doing on Allen is fantastic. What used to be a forgotten center median strip, has been transformed into a park-like environment with separate, dedicated paths for biking and walking. The DOT first claimed the road space by painting green, bollard-protected bike lanes, now they are going back and completing the full, capital project block-by-block. They are replacing the on-street protected bike lanes with dedicated, bike-only paths that wind through a gorgeous, park-like median.

Ride Along with Molly Fair-10

World Class transportation infrastructure-1

This facility on Allen is fantastic, but crossing Manhattan’s huge avenues can be a bit scary (especially since you’re way out there in the middle of the intersection). Thankfully, the crossings were actually easier thanks to Sandy. With all traffic signals still out due to the storm, we were personally shepherded across by traffic officers.

Ride Along with Molly Fair-12

The scramble across.
Ride Along with Molly Fair-11

Ride Along with Molly Fair-13

The post-Sandy bike crowds in Manhattan made the crossings much easier.

Once we successfully scrambled across the big streets like Delancey and Houston, we made our way onto the protected bike lanes on 1st Ave. This is another one of NYC DOT’s marquee projects. They took a major auto thoroughfare and implemented a transit-only lane on one side (they call it Select Bus Service) and a green, protected bike lane on the other. It’s beautiful on paper, but the reality can be a bit ugly; especially for a novice rider like Molly.

The bike lane is very frequently blocked by illegally parked cars and trucks, people routinely biking the wrong way (1st Ave is one-way), walkers, joggers, and then there are the “mixing zones” at every corner where bike operators must use caution and share the space momentarily while cars turn left. Each one of those hazards presents risks that could be enough to scare off timid riders.

NYC2012-1st Ave Protected bike lane-4

A common sight, especially on weekends.
NYC2012-1st Ave Protected bike lane-17

NYC2012-1st Ave Protected bike lane-16

A “mixing zone” in action.

As we made our way up 1st Ave, Molly was still riding calm and steady. She seemed to gain confidence with each obstacle we overcame and with each new spin of the cranks.

Ride Along with Molly Fair-14

We then headed west on 34th Street. That was a mistake. The street has no dedicated bike space and is only two lanes in each direction — with one of them being a busy, bus-only lane. And it was a slight uphill. I started to think that after such a pleasant ride, this last stretch would surely scare Molly off for good. Buses blared behind us, and cars came up fast when we tried to get out of the bus lane. We were in no man’s — or woman’s — land. Luckily, all four of us stayed strong and kept up a good pace.

Ride Along with Molly Fair-17

Ride Along with Molly Fair-16

I was too stressed out to focus the camera!

With a bit of relief, we reached Molly’s destination at 5th Ave. I didn’t have to wonder how she felt. The hug she gave our leader Chris and the big smile on her face said it all.

Ride Along with Molly Fair-18

Ride Along with Molly Fair-19

It took us about 38 minutes to get from the Fort Greene area of Brooklyn to 34th St and 5th Ave in Manhattan, a distance of about five miles. That’s comparable to transit on a normal day and twice as long as a car (without traffic). And — most importantly — almost the entire route was on protected bikeways. It was a real-life testament to the work NYC DOT is doing to prioritize bicycle travel.

The circumstances of Sandy got a lot of New Yorkers onto their bikes for the first time. What Molly shows us is that with a supportive community and excellent, bike-specific infrastructure, there’s a good chance many of them will will keep riding.

— This story comes from my recently completed trip to New York City, which was made possible by Planet Bike, Lancaster Engineering, and by readers like you. Thank you! You can find all my New York City coverage here.

Jonathan Maus (Publisher/Editor)

Jonathan Maus (Publisher/Editor)

Founder of BikePortland (in 2005). Father of three. North Portlander. Basketball lover. Car owner and driver. If you have questions or feedback about this site or my work, feel free to contact me at @jonathan_maus on Twitter, via email at maus.jonathan@gmail.com, or phone/text at 503-706-8804. Also, if you read and appreciate this site, please become a supporter.

Thanks for reading.

BikePortland has served this community with independent community journalism since 2005. We rely on subscriptions from readers like you to survive. Your financial support is vital in keeping this valuable resource alive and well.

Please subscribe today to strengthen and expand our work.

Notify of

newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Kiel Johnson / Go By Bike
Kiel Johnson
11 years ago

Go Bike Trains!!!!! Maybe this is something we should do at OHSU with the bike valet there…

11 years ago

four people is more like a bike streetcar than a bike train…


11 years ago
Reply to  BURR

Ha! 🙂

We’ve actually found that 4 or 5 is the ideal size here. I dream of bike boulevards full of biketrains like the kids have in Portland, but the realities of NYC streets are what they are. Leading any more riders, especially if most are not experienced commuters, is less than ideal. Once Jonathan gets those bike paratrooper teams in place, though, that could change . . . .

11 years ago

Jonathan, thank you for this fantastic write-up. Non-trivial fact: the NYC biketrain effort initially came about when I saw the Streetsfilm about the biketrains run for school kids in PDX I was a newly-minted #bikenyc commuter and thought I might have got back on my bike a lot sooner than I did if I’d had a biketrain. So it is especially heartening to read Molly’s story. If your readers are interested in keeping up with @NYCBiketrain, they can follow us on Twitter or the facespace thingamajig.

Kimberly Kinchen
Co-founder, NYC Biketrain

Kiel Johnson / Go By Bike
Kiel Johnson
11 years ago
Reply to  @NYCBiketrain

very cool! have you seen this? best spokeswomen for bike trains i know of http://www.nick.com/videos/clip/worldwide-day-of-play-2012-bike-train-clip.html

Paul in the 'couve
Paul in the 'couve
11 years ago

Yes – 34th street is NOT a bike friendly street. That’s one street I have learned to avoid almost entirely. BTW – I suggest NOT passing a bus that is blocking the traffic lane between 6th and 7th avenues on the yellow line – another bus might come the other way. One of my scariest cycling moments ever.

11 years ago


11 years ago

Excellent write-up, thank you so much Jonathan. So many of us are experienced riders that we forget what it’s like to have your nerves challenged by the *thought* of being run down. More often our own fears are more threatening than auto traffic itself, but it takes some time in the saddle to figure that out. Mentoring someone by showing them the routes and the ropes is extremely rewarding, and in the absence of a local bike train I encourage everyone to seek opportunities (especially at work) to get others less afraid of the road.

Congrats Molly and great work NYC Bike Train!

11 years ago

Jonathan, those separated bicycle and pedestrian paths in the median on Allen street look amazing. You clearly did a lot of work to get these aerial shots we’ve seen from your New York trip – thank you!

You might want to take another look at this line: “Once over the (relatively) long ride over the East River (it’s about a mile wider than the Willamette!)” The East River is about 2,000′ wide at the Manhattan Bridge, though viaducts on the approaches surely add to that. By comparison, the Willamette is about 1,400′ wide at the Hawthorne Bridge. So while the East River is definitely bigger, it’s nowhere close to a mile wider. The Hudson is about a mile wide between Manhattan and New Jersey, though.

Adams Carroll (News Intern)
Reply to  Elliot

Thanks Elliot,

My mistake. Got numbers mixed up. Edited the story. Basic idea was that the bridges are much more of a pedal than here in Portland!

Chris McNally
Chris McNally
11 years ago

Molly and Jesse, I hope we see you again on the Bike Train Thursday at Red Lantern.

Johnathan, this is a fabulous essay. You really documented the infrastructure well. You are an amazing photographer.

Paul, I was planning to take 33 or 35 but made a change because there were no operating traffic lights and crossing the Avenues seemed like it might be impossible without the NYPD officers on 34th. It was still a mistake though kind of exhilarating too.

I think we had six at the start but only 4 made it to Midtown. Others dropped off.

11 years ago

This was a great story for me to read first thing this morning thank you!

Dr. M
11 years ago

I loved the action shots in this piece! I’ve used the NYC Bike Lanes from Midtown down to lower Manhattan along the Hudson (Chelsea Piers) and it is SO much calmer than riding in rural NJ. Even with all of the traffic, cars (mostly cabs who are erratic yet professional drivers) are moving much slower than the ones blowing past me at 40 mph in the Garden State.

I still use my bicycle to get around in both states but the dedicated Bicycle Traffic Signals help avoid being hit at an intersection by turning cars. Just want to say God bless, Molly & Jesse! You could be complaining or sitting home making excuses but you guys got out there & made it happen. Well done!

11 years ago

I love the idea of having someone ride with inexperienced bicyclists during a commute to make it less scary! Does a program like that exist here in Portland?

Jeremy Cohen
Jeremy Cohen
11 years ago

What a great article. I think it is a great idea to take the bike train to schools and try to broaden its reach. There are some factors that make School based bike trains “easier”–uniform start time (as opposed to everyone getting to work when they do), common ending location (as opposed to common starting location, then having people have to “drop off”) and the close proximity of most neighborhood schools to the kids that ride there (as opposed to 5 miles from one borough to another). This only makes it MORE impressive that NYC does this and Molly tried it! Well done.

11 years ago

Good on her for taking it on. This might be worth a follow-up in the future to see if the cure stuck.