Support BikePortland

Subscriber Post - This post was written by a subscriber.
Want to subscribe? Learn More »

Tip your semi over on the sidewalk? No ticket!

Subscriber Post by Doug Klotz on August 9th, 2017 at 8:48 am

Semi trailer lies on its side, partly on sidewalk on Morrison bridge ramp.

Once again, a semi driver heading north on SE Grand has been going too fast, and missed the left turn onto the Morrison bridge ramp, tipping the vehicle over onto the bridge sidewalk. I’ve personally seen four of this type of crash at this location in the last decade. As far as I can tell, there hasn’t happened to be a pedestrian injured in any of these incidents.

The latest was on 8-7-17, about noon. I asked one of the Portland Police officers if the driver would be ticketed for reckless driving. He said, no, the driver is young, and just starting his career. “What purpose would it serve?” said the officer. “He’s already going to pay for the damage” “We can’t issue a ticket because we can’t find that he did this intentionally. He wasn’t DUII.” I asked if rolling your truck on a turn wasn’t evidence of reckless driving, or driving too fast. “He says a car cut him off. If we find a bicyclist under the trailer when we lift it up, then we’ll charge him”.

So there you have it. Tip a 40-ton vehicle onto the sidewalk? It’s not reckless driving. It is just, as the officer said, “an accident”.

NOTE: We love your comments and work hard to ensure they are productive, considerate, and welcoming of all perspectives. Disagreements are encouraged, but only if done with tact and respect. If you see a mean or inappropriate comment, please contact us and we'll take a look at it right away. Thank you — Jonathan

20
Leave a Reply

avatar
9 Comment threads
11 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
11 Comment authors
SpiffyB. CarfreeqJ_RPaul Atkinson Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Paul Atkinson
Guest
Paul Atkinson

“He says a car cut him off. If we find a bicyclist under the trailer when we lift it up, then we’ll charge him”

I actually believe that.

Probably they’ll charge him with recklessly taking the lane when the semi driver was rightfully turning nearby, riding without a helmet, wearing some non-reflective clothing, and dressing like Lance Armstrong.

rick
Guest
rick

don’t they have to yield to west-bound traffic?

Kyle Banerjee
Guest

He wouldn’t have been cut off by west-bound traffic. Rather it would be someone trying to slingshot around him before he got to the curve. I see people pull moves like that all the time.

Eric U.
Guest
Eric U.

I expect this will be problematic for his career anyway. Trucking companies know what is up.

B. Carfree
Guest
B. Carfree

Good trucking companies fire people who flip their rigs. Unfortunately, there are plenty of less than good trucking companies who hire these careless drivers and run them hard, often with ill-maintained equipment. Certain firms are notorious for this, like pretty much every firm that runs chip trucks in this state

Kyle Banerjee
Guest

Cars cut each other off all the time — and they especially cut off vehicles they don’t want to get stuck behind.

I know the BP way is to assume no driver is ever telling the truth and that they operate with wonton disregard and a total lack of skill, but what do people here think the driver should have been done if he were abruptly cut off and put in a situation where a collision was imminent — take no action and pulp the driver in his car?

Seems like the prudent thing to do would be to use everything the situation offered. If the handling limits of the vehicle didn’t allow it to be maneuvered into an open space, it could well be that risking rolling it onto space unoccupied by anyone else would be by far the best option. BTW, if the truck were loaded improperly (something the driver wouldn’t necessarily know), it could have a huge impact on the outcome.

Given how many people seem to lack the ability to stop or pull off an effective evasive move on a highly maneuverable bike going less than 15mph which can brake in a few feet to avoid getting hooked or cut off, y’all shouldn’t be so quick to cast stones at others.

q
Guest
q

I believe that’s “wanton” disregard, unless you’re referring to his disregard causing a dumpling of his load onto the street.

Spiffy
Subscriber

“take no action and pulp the driver in his car”

yes! don’t let the bad driver get away with no consequences… everybody needs to stop enabling bad driving, especially when you end up taking the fall for it like this truck driver…

I took this approach decades ago and have only had a couple people run into me…

B. Carfree
Guest
B. Carfree

It’s clear that you have never been trained to drive a truck. A big part of that training, explicitly spelled out in the literature one receives from most state licensing agencies, is to be aware of where every vehicle is on the road and what their speed, lane changes and other clues tell you about what they might do and to plan accordingly. Cars don’t come from out of nowhere. This guy should have seen this coming and slowed down before the car cut him off, assuming there even was a car that cut him off. Rolling the rig there is evidence of a poorly trained driver who should confine himself to class C vehicles.

Kyle Banerjee
Guest

I also see trucks moving too fast here. Vehicles in general move too fast here — there’s sometimes what amounts to a race from Grand to get in front. That entire area is problematic on a number of dimensions.

Maybe the driver was going too fast, maybe he wasn’t. But it’s a very realistic possibility that he was cut off while operating in a safe manner.

Whether he made an error or not, this will cause problems with a career where maintaining a clean MVR is important.

Evan
Guest
Evan

I think if you tip your vehicle on its side, you’ve done something wrong and should receive a citation. Drivers cut off trucks all the time, it’s true. That means it’s part of the job; the truck driver should have been prepared.

billyjo
Guest
billyjo

drivers ignore the bikes in the bike lanes when making a right turn…. the bikes should be prepared. Does your logic still hold up?

Spiffy
Subscriber

yes, the logic still holds up…

q
Guest
q

Why?

Spiffy
Subscriber

if a driver cuts you off and your evasive action makes you fall without contact and the driver (if they exist such as in this case) gets away without proof then you’ve done something wrong and enabled that driver to continue to cut off bikes…

J_R
Guest
J_R

Once again, the obvious solution is a stop sign enforcement action at Ladd’s Addition. It’s those damn bicyclists, again!

Spiffy
Subscriber

should be multiple violations… exceeding the basic speed law, and obstructing the sidewalk… you’re driving too fast if you tip over your truck on a corner…