Cool, thanks for all the helpful replies. Sounds like there is a bit of consensus on Finish Line CC being decent, so I will likely give that a try.
Ben, I hear ya on making sure the excess lube is cleaned from the outside of the chain after applying, and wiping the pulley wheels. That's generally part of my chain lubing routine.
I look forward to spending more time on the bike and less re-lubing my chain!
Scott